Best Pizza Stone Reviews For 2021

Note that the products discussed on our site are independently selected by us. At no extra cost to you, things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.

If you are in a hurry and just want to find out what the Best Pizza Stones are, then I’d recommend the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles as the best one.

It is becoming difficult or even impossible to get through a day or two without a crispy pizza. The best part of it all is when we get to make them ourselves.

But, making pizza is one thing, and getting it to taste like those from your favorite pizzeria is another. The question then is where lies the secret of making a great pizza?

The answer is in the best pizza stones.

This is a must-have if you want to be proud of your home-crafted pizza. But we all know that finding the right one for you can be overwhelming.

This is especially true with the variety of options there are in the market.

Further down this article is a guide to help you get the best pizza stones for the best pizza experience.

Top 5 Best Pizza Stones

Our Top Choice
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles, 14", Black
Product Name (Link Jumps To Our Review)
Customer Rating
More information
Unicook Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone, Baking Stone, Pizza Pan, Perfect for Oven, BBQ and Grill, Thermal Shock Resistant, 15x12 Inch Rectangular, 6.6Lbs
Product Name (Link Jumps To Our Review)
Customer Rating
More information
Best Price
Pizza Stone 12" x 15" Rectangular Baking & Grilling Stone, Perfect for Oven, BBQ and Grill. Innovative Double - faced Built - in 4 Handles Design
Product Name (Link Jumps To Our Review)
Customer Rating
More information
Honey-Can-Do Oven Round Pizza Stone
Product Name (Link Jumps To Our Review)
Customer Rating
More information
Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set, Stainless Steel
Product Name (Link Jumps To Our Review)
Customer Rating
More information

This product was presentation was made with AAWP plugin.


What Makes Good Pizza?

It is important that before going any further, we know what a good pizza is made up of. We should be able to describe or tell what a great pizza should be like, right?

To start with, what makes a pizza what it is, is the crust. The dough recipes you make use of does not affect the outcome of the pizza since they are all more or less similar.

Rather, what is important is how the dough is cooked, that is, whether it ends up soggy and moist, or crispy. Together with being crispy, a good pizza should be spotted with marks of brown.

All these characteristics and attributes can only be created when you use a pizza stone, and properly.


Benefits Of A Pizza Stone

Have you ever baked a pizza on your usual cookie sheet only to find out that the crispiness and browning of the crust is nothing compared to the standard pizzeria pie?

The possible reasons are

a) the limitation in how hot your oven gets, compared to commercial ovens,

and b) the limitation on how much heat a cookie sheet is capable of holding because of its thin nature.

This is where pizza stone gets to help – to handle extreme heat which in turn makes the cooking of your pizza to be even.

This way, you can achieve not just faster-prepared pizza, but a healthier and crispier crust as well.

Wondering what secret is behind the function of the stone? It lies in how the stone is structured, which makes it absorb adequate moisture from the dough.

Additionally, it is easy to use and maintain these stones.


Types Of Pizza Stone

Pizza stones are generally categorized based on the materials that are used in their manufacture.

There are different materials used in making this tool, and contrary to the name (pizza stone), not all pizza stones are made of stones.

It is important that you know the various options and how they compare; as this will help you decide on your best fit. Let’s look at a few:

1. Cordierite

Every pizza enthusiast can relate to this material as it is the most used of all in making pizza stones.

As a mineral that it is, it is known for handling a high level of temperatures and resists thermal shock pretty well. This implies that no matter the transitioning between low and high temperatures, they will not break.

Additionally, these properties make them able to absorb heat and in turn evenly radiate them out and consistently.

Also, it is able to absorb and soak up moisture while the pizza is baking, thus, producing a characteristic crispy crust. This option comes in handy when you’ll be baking two or more pizzas.

2. Ceramic

This is the most cost-effective choice of material for a pizza stone.

They are a mixture of fire kiln and clay and can conduct heat at very high temperatures. They in turn evenly radiate this heat, thus giving rise to nothing less than a great pizza.

Compared to material like cordierite stone, they are quite fragile, but with proper care can be made to last for a long time. They are very light in texture which makes handling them a breeze.

They come in different shapes and sizes, and so it shouldn’t be difficult to find an option that fits your oven.

3. Stone and Clay

This type of pizza stone is actually considered the best when it comes to baking pizzas as they have superb moisture absorbing characteristics.

This singular characteristic is invaluable as it is at the center of what a pizza is actually all about. Otherwise, all you will get is a gross or soggy crust.

With this amazing property come some downsides too. It takes a long time, as much as 30 minutes to preheat before the actual cooking.

Also, they tend to easily break or crack; and cleaning can be difficult.

4. Steel

In recent times, this type of pizza stone has risen in popularity.

The level at which they absorb and conduct high heat is quite impressive. Plus you don’t have to worry about any thermal shock experience.

They are very thick and do not easily crack or break. In fact, in contact with say your tile floor, you should be more worried about your floor-breaking or cracking.

Owing to its thickness, they are somewhat heavy and this makes handling them quite some task.

For next-level performance, try adding it to a stone, (say on top of the stone). The outcome will no doubt be anything short of amazing.


Factors To Consider When Buying The Best Pizza Stone

1. Thickness

How thick your pizza stone is will influence how efficient it is in maintaining and regulating heat around its surface evenly.

The best pizza stone is supposed to be adequately thick so it can contain and maintain a moderate amount of heat, and distribute all around its surface.

Its thickness also goes a long way to determine the dexterity and durability, since it is able to handle a lot of pressure and heat.

It is important to note that the thicker, the heavier and harder it is to handle the tool. As much as you want something that suits your heat requirement, it should also suit your weight requirement.

2. Size and shape

The importance of pizza stone size cannot be overemphasized. It is as important as the material used in making the stone.

While a round-shaped stone is a standard and basic shape, there are other shapes that should be considered as well, at least for the wellbeing of your pizza.

For size too, you want to consider how much space your oven can accommodate.

The idea is that you will need a fair enough surface area to allow for easy scooting and rotating of the pie for even baking. A rectangular stone is more likely to produce this effect. There’s also the option of a square stone.

3. Material

We have already established that pizza stones are generally made from many different materials. These are responsible for how the heat that comes from the oven is being regulated and induced.

As much as there is a general standard texture for pizza, personal preference also comes into play here, especially since it is made from home.

Your preferred texture, whether moist, crunchy, or soft, will go a long way to determine the material your stone is made of.


Best Pizza Stones Reviews

Best Pizza Stones


Editor Review 1

This product was presentation was made with AAWP plugin.

Are you looking for all-weather cookware that comes in handy at times when you crave great tasting pizza? You got yourself one of the best pizza stones – Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan.

It is durable and sturdy, and if cared for properly can last decades.

This non-traditional pizza stone comes equipped with well-positioned side loop handles that offer a great deal of grip and ease in maneuvering.

It also features a rim which helps to hold your pizza and prevent any form of sliding out of the cookware.

The Lodge pizza stone comes pre-seasoned and as such whether you add oils or not, you won’t need to worry about your pizza sticking.

This of course also implies that the cleanup process takes little to no effort a breeze since there is usually no debris left off.

A common characteristic of cast iron is its weightiness/heaviness, and this can make it a little difficult to handle.

But, cast iron is known for its excellent heat retention capabilities, thus allowing for even cooking of all your pizzas. This assures a better and crispier crust at the end of the day.

This is quite a versatile pizza stone, as its working is not limited to use on an oven or making pizza, but is compatible with varied cook-tops and can be used for preparing the likes of pancakes, steaks, bread, burgers, and all kinds of “frying” and “roasting”.

It is affordableIt feels quite heavy
It is equipped with large handles for better controlSliding off pizza may be difficult because of the rim
Its heat retention is unparalleled
It distributes heat heating
It is versatile
It is easy to clean
It comes pre-seasoned with natural oil

Check Price on Amazon


Editor Review 2

This product was presentation was made with AAWP plugin.

This is a must-have kitchen collection if you desire to make a delicious, well-cooked pizza. It comes at a budget-friendly price too.

The Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone is made of Cordierite stone with the capacity to heat as much as 1450 degrees Fahrenheit.

This information speaks volumes of the benefits you’d expect to get from the cookware. To begin with, its high heat capacity means that it can achieve the required temperature to create an exceptional pizza. The way you have it in your favorite pizzeria shop.

This also translates to having superior moisture absorption (thanks to the invisible micro-pores) for those crispy pizza crusts.

Furthermore, its heat retention is second to none, thus creating an even distribution of heat around its surface and to your pizza.

This stone also boasts of an exceptional thermal shock resistance which comes in handy during fluctuation of temperature. Making sure your food still gets to cook evenly.

If you have always been looking to prepare delicious and healthy pizzas like the pizzerias and surprise your family and friends, this cookware model is no doubt for you.

It is needless to say that the Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone is durable and versatile too.

It possesses exceptional resistance to thermal shockIt tends to emit a chemical smell
It comes with a plastic scraper you can use in trimming and cleaning
Its heat retention capability is quite impressive
It comes in 3 round sizes
It is versatile

Check Price on Amazon


Editor Review 3

This product was presentation was made with AAWP plugin.

One pizza stone that will surely give you a fantastic pizza-making experience is the ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone.

As small as it is, it guarantees a tasty pizza crust the way you love it. It is designed for ovens with limited space.

They are made from popular cordierite which already ensures its even heat distribution for balanced cooking.

And also efficiently absorbs moisture from the dough. This way, a crispy browned crust, and the best dough is all you expect at the end of the day.

It heats up very fast (despite its thickness) and unlike a lot of other stones will not need a long time of preheating before the actual cooking.

The ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone comes equipped with a well-enough thickness (0.6″) which makes it able to handle a great measure of heat and pressure and so is perfect for preparing a variety of foods without any form of damage experienced.

It features few divots designed to serve as its handles. This of course helps to save space and cut weight.

More than just making pizzas, the ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone can be used for baking bread, biscuits, cookies, and so on.

It is easy to useIt can easily get stained
It is versatileIt is a bit heavy
It is easy to clean
It offers added convenience with its built-in double-faced handles
It heats up pretty fast
It withstands high temperatures without breaking

Check Price on Amazon


Editor Review 4

This product was presentation was made with AAWP plugin.

A great way to home-cook and still guarantee a restaurant-quality pizza crust is with the use of the Old Stone Oven Round Pizza Stone.

It comes in a surface dimension of 16.5” and thus offers a lot of space for making large enough pizza capable of feeding a crowd.

Additionally, you can easily scoot and rotate your pie where necessary.

This stone features a mix of lead-free clays and is designed for durability and toughness. It also features a standard thickness that helps it handle rapid changes in temperature.

This stone possesses the capability to absorb your oven’s heat and distribute it across its surface to your foods. This is doubtless how you get your pizza tasting delicious with that sought-after golden-brown crust guaranteed with every bite.

At the bottom, you will find its edges a bit raised to make picking it up out of the oven easier.

Cleaning and maintaining this cookware is easy to do. This can be achieved with the help of warm water and sponge; after which you allow to dry.

It is easy to cleanIt permeates with a foul chemical smell
It is easy to use with its raised edges
It provides a large cooking surface
It handles pressure and heat fairly enough
It is sturdy and durable
It provides even and rapid heating

Check Price on Amazon


Editor Review 5

This product was presentation was made with AAWP plugin.

If you’re looking for a cookware set that helps you to prepare a pizza with ease, look no further than the Cuisinart CPS-445 3-Piece Pizza Stone Set.

This is one tool that has all you need to create the perfect pizza. It comes in a lighter weight compared to a lot of other stones. This of course makes it easy to handle – lifting it in and out of your oven.

It also comes with a pizza cutter to make for an efficient and easy cutting, and a pizza peel for easy pick up out of the oven.

The Cuisinart CPS-445 3-Piece Pizza Stone Set is made from a combination of lead-free clay and ceramic, thus taking its durability to the next level.

It heats super fast and takes a very short time to preheat. It perfectly imitates standard commercial pizza-making conditions.

It possesses a thermal resistance of up to 800° and ensures heat is distributed across the stone’s surface, thus eliminating any form of hot spots.

It is budget-friendlyCleaning can be quite a task
It is lightweightIt usually emits a faint odor
It retains heat well enough
It is versatile
It heats up really fast

Check Price on Amazon


Final Words On Best Pizza Stones

I hope you find the above guide useful in helping you choose the best pizza stone to suit your needs.

The above list of products was carefully researched and recommended for the best pizza-making experience.

If I am to pick one out of them all, my top pick would go the Lodge Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles and the reason are not far-fetched.

It is made with quality material and as such is durable.

Its capability for heat retention is also second to none; and this itself is a basic criterion for achieving a perfectly crispy crust. It is one of the few stones to come pre-seasoned, leaving you less worried about adding oils so your pizza doesn’t stick.

It comes with enough thickness to handle the necessary heat required to make your pizza turning out like those from your favorite pizzeria shop.

The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles is one pizza stone I would recommend any day anytime.

Did you like “Best Pizza Stone Reviews”? We would greatly appreciate it if you would share this on your favorite social media channel.

Last update on 2021-01-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.